‘Split’ Is Not As Problematic As We Thought

Split is the latest film from director M. Night Shyamalan (director of blockbusters like The Sixth Sense and extraordinarily awful flops like The Last Airbender). It’s a thriller about a man with dissociative identity disorder who kidnaps three teenage girls. When the trailer came out, it was criticized for perpetuating a dangerous stigma around with people with D.I.D. The trailer portrayed Kevin, the lead character with D.I.D as an antagonist, and almost made it look as though his disorder gave him superpowers. It was something that should have been criticized. The movie itself, however, was widely different.

In the movie, it was made clear that the character with D.I.D. was an outlier, a special case. Kevin’s doctor mentioned that several other patients she worked with who were doing very well and had fulfilling lives. She seemed to truly care for her patients and fought to have them recognized. Her character also accurately explained D.I.D., which is important as it brings real support and awareness to the disorder to audiences who may not believe that it’s real.  The film also showed that Kevin developed D.I.D. as a coping mechanism for abuse, and it was made clear that although it did help him, it wasn’t something to be praised nor did it give him “super powers”.  There is a fantastical element to the film in which characters have “superpowers”, but it was not related to Kevin’s disorder (the film exists in the same universe as Unbreakable, a 2000 Shyamalan film). The superpower part really just brought up a discussion about how much the mind was capable of. This aspect of the film was not supposed to be a direct representation of mental illness, it was more of a thought on what powers the mind holds.

Kevin wasn’t even made to be evil, he was shown to just want to be accepted and you really felt for him.

Some people thought it was transphobic, but I personally didn’t see that. The character with D.I.D. had a few female personalities, but I didn’t feel they were intended to be comic relief. One had a very integral part in the story. The lead character Casey was very strong and was shown to be smart, not a sad victim.  She was able to connect to Kevin as she had experienced and was experiencing trauma and abuse. The movie really touched on how different people deal with trauma, which is important to understand.  The other girls that were kidnapped were also strong characters as well, as they fought back instead of waiting to be rescued.

Although Split is not free of flaws, it was much better than expected and had some really good parts. It touched on how different people deal with trauma, presented D.I.D. as a real disorder, brought up various issues with abuse and assault, and the character with D.I.D. wasn’t shown to be completely “crazy” and “evil”. All in all, it was an enjoyable, deep thriller that should be a positive turning point for director M. Night Shyamalan.

Comments

comments

  1. I have DID, and there’s just a few things I’d like to say, if that’s okay.
    First of all, I appreciate the fact that you’ve taken the time to address the issues we would have a problem with (e.g. people not believing it’s real, that we’re tired of ppl with DID in film being portrayed as “evil.)
    I think the challenging part of a review is that it’s based on a unique perspective of the person doing the reviewing. I think I can safely say that most people are not going to approach the movie as intellectually as you have attempted to do, so what they take away from the movie is going to be what most people have taken away from other movies: that is that DID makes you crazy, dangerous, psychotic, sociopathic, etc. I feel that the damage and stigma is still present in this film to the degree that it still does us harm, mostly not because of the movie itself, but because it’s just one of many like it. There is almost no popular literature which accurately describes DID. And even though this movie did in fact attempt to address and describe some truth to the disorder, the fact that it was within the context of a horror movie pretty much makes it irrelevant. It almost makes it worse, because truth mixed with some error makes is worse than just error.
    That being said, I saw your comments on twitter and appreciate you being open-minded about your review, and how sensitive you were to our perspectives on the movie, in light of the review.
    As someone with DID, I can honestly say that I do understand your viewpoint. I disagree with it, mostly just because of the history of DID stigma and a personal opinion about how the movie comes off, but you reviewed the movie with knowledge of our concerns and did not just dismiss them as “oversensitive.”
    I’ve had the opportunity to discuss this movie with many people, and most are hateful, judgmental, and immediately accuse me of being oversensitive. Thank you for your openness to our thoughts on this (as you expressed on twitter.)

  2. As a conglomerate of identities who have been struggling for over a year with our own integration and healing process, we all found Split to be incredibly validating, cathartic, illuminating and accurate. This is Alex, currently in the light, but the rest say, “hi”. Thanks for the article.

  3. Good – I should certainly pronounce, impressed with your site. I had no trouble navigating through all the tabs and related info ended up being truly simple to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Quite unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or something, web site theme . a tones way for your customer to communicate. Excellent task..

  4. Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read something like this before. So good to find any person with some unique ideas on this subject. realy thanks for starting this up. this website is something that’s wanted on the web, somebody with a bit of originality. helpful job for bringing one thing new to the web!

  5. This can be the proper blog for any one who wants to find out about this subject. You understand so considerably its practically hard to argue with you (not that I actually would want…HaHa). You undoubtedly put a brand new spin on a topic thats been written about for years. Excellent stuff, just fantastic!

Leave a Reply
Your email address will not be published.

Click on the background to close